Pine and oak floors are among the most popular floors for modern homes. Both possess rustic and unique natural charm, with prominent wood effects.
Aesthetics aside, there are key differences in terms of strength, resilience, and maintenance of pine vs oak flooring that are crucial to consider.
Keep reading to learn the difference between pine vs oak flooring and which one is best for your home.
Which is Better, Oak or Pine?
Oak flooring is considered rarer and slightly more luxurious compared to pine. Oak grows slower compared to pine and therefore isn’t as readily available.
Yet there’s other differences. Oak flooring is strong, durable, and responds well to stain, so it’s widely considered to be a cost-effective long-term investment. Its rich color and soft grain also offer an unrivalled natural aesthetic in the home.
Pine is also a sturdy choice of floor, but, as a softer wood, it’s more prone to dent over time compared to oak with the exception of heart pine. Its unique coloring is a classic choice, but it’s seen as more unique in modern homes compared to other alternatives.
What’s the Difference Between Pine and Oak Flooring?
Primarily, oak flooring is stronger than pine wood floors. It’s a hardwood, rather than a softwood, which means it’s tougher, denser, and more resilient. Owed to its density, it’s harder to scratch, dent, or wear.
Aesthetically, pine and oak flooring both offer character and charm, with a range of hues available. Pine tends to be more available in traditionally orange tones, while oak hardwood flooring comes in dark, light, gray, and white colors.
Both kinds of wood can be stained, but oak responds better to stain compared to pine. It’s generally why there’s more variety of oak floor colors and a limited choice with pinewood.
Oak flooring also has a more pronounced grain compared to pine wood, giving it a distinct natural look.
What Lasts Longer, Pine or Oak?
Any solid wood flooring, including pine and oak, lasts a long time. With proper care and maintenance, hardwood floors last for decades. But in reality, oak flooring should last longer than pine.
Pine is a softer wood than oak, with a Janka rating (a universally acknowledged strength test for wood) of 1290. Oak holds a rating of 1360, leaving it with a moderately higher score compared to pine.
Is Pine or Oak More Expensive?
Oak wood flooring tends to be more expensive compared to pine flooring. The value of wood generally depends on how popular it is, its unique characteristics, and the complexity of the growing process.
Pine trees grow significantly faster compared to oak trees, making pinewood more readily available. This is why oak can be more expensive. The characteristics of oak also make it more desirable, which contributes to its higher value.
Is Oak or Pine Easier to Stain?
Unlike maple or cherry, oak and pine woods are relatively easy to stain. Staining pine can be slightly trickier, as the soft nature of the wood is prone to uneven color absorption or blotching. Generally, pine tends to look better in its natural golden orange state, which is why it isn’t commonplace to stain it a different color.
Oak is considerably more porous compared to pine, so it takes stain well and uses much less of it. Stained oak also boldens the natural grain, giving it more character and an enhanced texture. Different stains can also completely transform the overall coloring of oak.
Pine Flooring
Solid pine wood flooring is a good choice for the home. It’s considered affordable, particularly for large, open-plan spaces, and offers adequate resilience. Being a softwood, it isn’t as durable as hardwood, yet it still takes some heavy destruction to damage pine wood surfaces.
While hardwood offers better resilience, it’s just as prone to damage if heavy items are dropped or sharp edges scratch along the floors. Therefore, even though pine is a softer wood, it can be considered just as resilient in the home compared to other hardwood floors.
Are Pine Floors Popular?
Pinewood often gets confused with knotty pine, which is considered a more traditional wood to use for flooring and wall paneling. Knotty pine has a distinctive orange wood color with prominent knots throughout the boards. Clear pine is considered a more popular flooring for modern homes, with a range of colors available and slightly less pronounced knotholes.
Can Pine Flooring Be Refinished?
Pine hardwood can be re-stained to rejuvenate the color, fix blemishes, or change the hue of the hardwood entirely. Sanding pine floors can be done, but it has its downfalls. Refinishing any solid wood flooring removes the natural grain effect on the surface, leaving the floor completely smooth.
This isn’t a problem, but it can change the aesthetic and value of the flooring drastically. Sanded pine floors can look more akin to laminate flooring rather than solid engineered wood, which reduces the element of luxury natural wood floors bring to a room.
Refinishing solid wood also removes the top layer, which can reduce its resilience and leave it more vulnerable to damage. During the refinishing process, care should be taken, as, being a softwood, pine can dent or scratch easily, particularly when the finish has been removed.
Oak Flooring
Is Oak a Good Choice For Flooring?
Oak has always been one of the most popular hardwood floor colors. It’s strong and highly resilient against dents and scratches. Most people choose oak floors not just for its strength, but because of its aesthetics and popularity.
Considered a rare and luxurious wood, oak comes in a variety of natural finishes that suit any twenty-first-century décor, including white oak or red oak.
What is a Disadvantage of Oak?
Oak tends to be more expensive compared to other woods, owed to its high demand and longer growing process. It can also be considered slightly less sustainable compared to other softwoods with a shorter growing cycle, like pine.
These qualities boost the desirability of oak floors, but can also make oak slightly less accessible for larger spaces or projects with a modest budget. Luxury vinyl flooring that looks like wood or oak laminate can be a more suitable alternative.
Summary
Both oak vs pine hardwood floors are a strong, long-lasting, and visually appealing choice for the home. Oak has slightly more benefits compared to pine, being stronger and widely considered more luxurious, yet pine is just as resilient with the right care.
Considering oak or pine in your home? See what our flooring looks like in your home with our room visualizer!
